3 Questions and a Song

Episode 129 of 3 Questions and a Song welcomes rising singer-songwriter Bay Simpson, fresh off his breakout appearance on NBC’s The Voice Season 29, where he earned a coveted chair turn from Adam Levine. In this exclusive interview, Bay dives deep into the inspiration behind his powerful new single “Too Good to Be True,” set for release on April 10, 2026. Hailing from Muscle Shoals and now making waves in Nashville, Bay Simpson is quickly becoming a name to watch in the modern rock and singer-songwriter scene. “Too Good to Be True” is a nostalgic rock anthem that reflects on growing up in the early 2010s, capturing the emotional realization that some of life’s most meaningful moments are only fully understood after they’ve passed.

Written alongside acclaimed songwriters Brian Maher and James LeBlanc—who have worked with artists like Taylor Swift, Kenny Chesney, and Rascal Flatts—the song delivers a heartfelt message wrapped in soaring melodies and emotionally driven lyrics. The unforgettable refrain, “It was too good, too good to be true,” resonates with listeners who remember the transition from analog youth to a digitally dominated world.

In this episode, Bay answers three insightful questions about his journey, his songwriting process, and the meaning behind his music, followed by a featured play of “Too Good to Be True.” Fans of rock music, indie artists, and emerging talent will find this episode packed with inspiration, storytelling, and authentic musical passion.

If you’re searching for new music, discovering independent artists, or looking for the next breakout star from The Voice, this episode is a must-listen.