Conversations with Stephen Kamugasa
Why Genocide Is The Responsibility Of The Entire World
Listen on
Episode notes
Detailed Synopsis
Understanding Genocide: A Global Responsibility
In a thought-provoking podcast episode, Dr. Omar McDoom stresses the global responsibility of recognising genocide. He delves into the complexities of genocide, with a specific focus on the Rwandan genocide, emphasising the importance of understanding its causes and contexts to prevent future atrocities and foster reconciliation.
Importance of Understanding Genocide
Prevention: Dr. McDoom highlights the significance of comprehending the factors that lead to genocide to prevent similar events in the future. By understanding these root causes, the international community can proactively address underlying issues and take measures to prevent future genocides.
Reconciliation: The podcast episode underscores the importance of understanding the motivations behind genocidal acts for post-conflict reconciliation. By gaining a comprehensive understanding of these motivations, societies can work towards healing, restoring communities, and promoting coexistence.
Global Impact: Dr. McDoom's research on the Rwandan genocide emphasises that genocide has far-reaching implications beyond local or regional boundaries. The aftermath of genocide can impact international relations, human rights, peace, and security. Therefore, a thorough understanding of genocide is crucial for the global community to address and prevent such atrocities.
Role of the International Community
United Nations Security Council: Despite its limitations, the UN Security Council remains a critical platform for addressing genocide and armed conflicts. Dr. McDoom stresses the need for the Security Council to play a proactive role in preventing genocide and promoting global peace.
International Criminal Court (ICC): The ICC is highlighted as a key institution for holding individuals accountable for war crimes and atrocities. Dr. McDoom emphasises the importance of supporting a rules-based system and strengthening the ICC to ensure accountability for violations of international law.
Lessons from Rwanda
Securocratic State Building: The concept of a securocratic state builder in Rwanda, prioritizing security above all else, raises concerns about long-term sustainability and its implications for human rights and freedoms. While Rwanda has made progress post-genocide, the emphasis on security poses significant challenges.
Polarization and Truth-Telling: Ongoing controversies in Rwanda, such as the Safety Bill and reactions to the UK's proposed asylum scheme to export refugees to Rwandan, underscore the importance of truth-telling and transparency in post-genocide contexts. Understanding the complexities faced by countries like Rwanda is crucial for promoting accountability, justice, and reconciliation globally.
In conclusion, the podcast episode emphasises that genocide is a shared responsibility that requires a deep understanding of its causes, contexts, and consequences. By actively working towards prevention, reconciliation, and truth-telling, the international community can strive towards a more peaceful and just world.
The definition of genocide is a contentious issue due to its moral gravity and varied uses in legal, scholarly, and popular contexts. Dr. Omar McDoom discusses how genocide is considered the "crime of crimes," representing the most heinous crime that can be committed by a state or people against another group. The stigma associated with genocide makes it challenging for individuals or countries to accept the label, leading to debates over its definition.
Dr. McDoom explains that the debate over the definition of genocide arises from different perspectives and purposes for using the term. Lawyers focus on accountability, scholars seek to understand the causes of genocide, and communities use the term to draw attention to their plight. The legal definition of genocide, outlined in the 1948 UN Convention on Genocide, requires a specific intent to destroy a group, leading to scholarly debates over interpretation.
Furthermore, Dr. McDoom highlights how scholars have broadened the definition of genocide over time to include deliberate and organised actions beyond physical destruction. This expanded view reflects the complexity and gravity of genocide as a crime.
The UN Security Council remains a crucial institution in addressing armed conflicts and preventing genocide, despite its limitations. Dr. Omar McDoom underscores the importance of the Security Council as a forum for debating and potentially acting on issues of international peace and security. While acknowledging challenges, Dr. McDoom emphasises the need for a rules-based system and continued support for institutions like the ICC to maintain accountability and prevent conflicts.
Time-stamp
[00:02:24] Father's influence on worldview.
[00:05:15] Wrongful accusation and arrest.
[00:11:16] Empathy towards genocide perpetrators.
[00:16:45] What is genocide defined as?
[00:22:28] Understanding the concept of genocide.
[00:23:13] Genocidal violence and communication.
[00:30:18] Humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
[00:33:00] Unusual features in Rwanda.
[00:39:55] Competitive politics in Rwanda.
[00:44:39] The importance of UN Security Council.
[00:48:40] International Criminal Court's effectiveness.
[00:53:49] Rwanda as a safe haven.
[00:55:47] The polarization on Rwanda.
[01:00:16] The securocratic state building model.
[01:06:01] Impact on civil liberties.