The Blue Collar Future

Union vs Non-Union: What Really Matters?

Listen on

Episode notes

Jaden Robison delves into the heated debate of union versus non-union work on the Blue Collar Future podcast. From his perspective as a third-generation concrete finisher, he explores the pros and cons of union membership, reflecting on pay, benefits, seniority, and individual recognition. Jaden shares personal experiences and discusses common misconceptions about family-run businesses. With varying perspectives on unions' importance, especially in right-to-work states like Utah, this episode encourages listeners to consider their unique circumstances and invites further discussion on the topic.

Key Takeaways:

  • The strength and effectiveness of a union largely depend on its presence and influence within a geographical area or specific trade.

  • Family-run businesses can present unique challenges and benefits, with success often hinging on maintaining professionalism and open communication.

  • Union membership typically guarantees higher pay and better benefits, but also ties employees to union rules and decisions, which may sometimes be limiting.

  • Working within non-union environments can offer greater opportunity for rapid advancement for individuals who demonstrate exceptional performance and commitment.

  • Jaden emphasizes the value of evaluating one's local labor market and specific trade before making decisions about joining a union.

Notable Quotes:

  1. "If you live in an area with a strong union presence, with a lot of strong unions, it seems to be a no-brainer to be in the union."

  2. "The pros for unions are typically a guaranteed higher pay, consistent work and stable work, and more benefits than you would get non-union."

  3. "The main draw to being in a non-union position is that you actually get compensated for being an excellent employee, learning fast, showing up on time, you know, doing your job really well."

Share your feedback and experience!!